Apple v. Samsung: Sealed Files, First Amendment Fears

Written by Tom Ewing

It’s a question of the First Amendment. Or should judges allow Apple and Samsung to continually seal public documents during trial. Our Tom Ewing investigates.


Photo: Gina Smith for aNewDomain.net

The word “seal” appears 1,319 times in the docket for the Apple v. Samsung patent infringement case.

The sealed submissions and sealed files encompass more than just the two litigants, Apple and Samsung. It so far includes sealed submissions from such major tech companies as IBM, Research in Motion, InterDigital, Philips, Toshiba, Microsoft, Intel, Motorola Mobility, Ericsson, Dolby, Siemens, Nokia and Qualcomm.

Some parties — InterDigital and Motorola Mobility — have even requested that the courtroom be closed during any testimony their reps provide.

Sealed submissions are becoming typical in patent law. Even transcripts of court proceedings can go under seal.

Would you believe that, in a few patent cases, nearly everything but the judge’s rulings has been sealed? Wo ho ho! It’s true.

Now most patent cases don’t draw the media scrutiny of Apple v. Samsung and the not-that-surprising demands for information. Reuters America LLC has filed several motions with the court in an effort to keep the trial’s proceedings more open.

The tension in this case lies between the U.S. First Amendment right to know what transpires in court proceedings versus a litigant’s right to protect confidential business information, trade secrets or internal product roadmaps.

Apple’s work on various products came to light day one of the trial, when Apple designer Christopher Stringer testified and brought Apple various prototype iPhone devices up to the stand.

And Reuters attorneys submitted several exhibits that purport to show much sealed information is already publicly known.

In one motion, Reuter’s attorneys argued, “this trial court is a public governmental institution, and neither Apple nor Samsung can fight over billions of dollars in a public courtroom and expect to have the information upon which this case turns shielded from public view.” In their briefs, Reuters’ attorneys cite various US and California supreme court rulings regarding open and public civil trials.

Some of the judge’s comments seem to echo Reuters’ arguments. In a July 18 20122 hearing, Judge Lucy Koh told attorneys:

… All of the marketing stuff? Public documents. Okay? All of the design developments, public document… It’s all going to be public. … I’ve told you, other than some third party source code, I don’t really plan on sealing anything.

The judge has yet to rule on the Reuters motions.

For their parts, the computer and telecom companies argue that the law protects their otherwise confidential business information. Nokia’s attorneys even argued that there is no “public interest” in the case. “While the products are highly popular, the parties are major corporations, and the facts are juicy and salacious (who copied whom, who destroyed documents and what evidence should be heard), the legal issues are routine patent infringement questions. Hence, while the public is interested, the ‘public interest’ is not at stake,” says a Nokia document.

Reuters also submitted a declaration signed by four patent law professors. It opposed the general proposition of sealing court records. The law professors wrote:

It is our belief that making licensing data more widely available can help reduce these market inefficiencies by providing credible and comparable information to parties, scholars, and courts wrestling with the difficult question of what a patent is worth.

In their brief, Reuters’attorneys also quoted Judge Alsup’s testy response under somewhat similar circumstances during Oracle v. Google in April. After Google attempted to seal certain financial information, the judge in that case ruled:

Oh, come on. Oh, come on. This is a public trial. Denied. Denied.

Reuters attorneys argued:

Apple’s attempt to minimize the public interest in disclosure of the material it tries to seal is flawed for three reasons. First, the burden is not upon those seeking access to show the public interest in disclosure of court documents, it is upon those attempting to rebut the strong presumption of access. Second, Apple’s manufacturing processes and overseas costs are a matter of tremendous public interest: Apple recently “agreed to allow” a human rights investigation into its Asian subsidiaries, and the resulting report contained wage and hour information. Third, the public will not be able to understand the companies’ damages cases without the information they now seek to seal, especially since the damages issues will be interwoven with infringement and invalidity issues.

Here’s the full complaint — Apple v. Samsung.
Apple Samsung Lawsuit

21 Comments

  • Achieve an online presence that delivers the very best…….

    Web application development

  • Upgrade consumers with inexperienced help every step of the way from design and to development………….

    Website design Bangalore

  • Emphasis on progress and assimilation of accurate software system……


    Web application development Bangalore

  • Website Design Bangalore dedicated in beautiful design and programming affordable price. Website Design Bangalore comprises many different skills and disciplines in the production and maintenance of websites. Website Design Bangalore submission Logo Design, Web site Designers, Designing to small and medium businesses in Bangalore. Website Design Bangalore is a communal of designers and site owners sharing free web design templates, website templates.

    Website design Bangalore

  • Website
    Design Bangalore dedicated in beautiful
    design and programming affordable price. Website
    Design Bangalore comprises many different
    skills and disciplines in the production and maintenance of websites. Website
    Design Bangalore submission Logo Design, Web
    site Designers, Designing to small and medium businesses in Bangalore. Website
    Design Bangalore is a communal of designers
    and site owners sharing free web design templates, website templates.

    Website design
    Bangalore

    Website
    Designing Bangalore Web page overhauling is an absolute necessity for
    fulfilling dependable client conservation. Website
    Designing Bangalore allows customers to mix-and-match compare or choose a
    best-suited product/solution. Website
    Designing Bangalore Customize solutions with configurations based on pre-set
    permutations & combinations. Website
    Designing Bangalore Connect with the customer’s interests and generate
    qualified leads.

    Website Designing
    Bangalore

  • Web Application Development Bangalore in cooperating the aforesaid into the developed client projects in accordance to their requirements. Web Application Development Bangalore has provided more effective and productive solutions for our clients in recent past. Web Application Development Bangalore in the Web solutions for the websites developed at Web Application Development Bangalore have become more relevant for key problems wherein incorporation of practical web solutions play the key role in customer satisfaction. Web application development Bangalore highly specialized and focused area requiring a lot of research and brainstorming. Web application development Bangalore is providing an optimized and most cost-effective website design for the developed website.

    Web Application Development Bangalore

    Ecommerce Development Bangalore developers in India develop strong, springy, beneficial online shops with business growing in mind. Ecommerce Development Bangalore helps you takes full advantage of every sales opportunity. Ecommerce Development Bangalore gains a competitive edge. Ecommerce Development Bangalore accumulation to make or break a sale, lure-in customers or drive them away. The quality and cohesiveness of the Ecommerce Development Bangalore fundamentals in your website says a lot approximately you and your online business. A successful Ecommerce Development Bangalore not only looks good, but also performs in bringing revenue. Ecommerce Development Bangalore can provide enormously, cost-effective development without compromising on quality.

    Ecommerce Development Bangalore

  • Windows Application Development Bangalore will be this specific fast paced planet of development as well as unique. Windows Application Development Bangalore for seeable to touch any describe of mobile phone customers on this planet. Windows Application Development Bangalore re marketers will be directed at the particular mobile phone apps to help upgrade their particular business into a new level.

    Windows Application Development Bangalore

  • Ecommerce Development Bangalore shopping cart application is use to enable you to advertise the merchandise for your target audience worldwide. Ecommerce Development Bangalore is can certainly both always be implement just as one self-sufficient part or began this morning a good online business web development wrap jointly. Ecommerce Development Bangalore is aspect associated with increased accomplish in order to men and women around the world is taller on the subject of online business.

    Ecommerce Development Bangalore

  • Luxury Mattress Bangalore is quilting having superb types on cozy stretchable white-colored. Luxury Mattress Bangalore is much smoother when compared to boned springtime 1. Luxury Mattress Bangalore continual layout up-gradation with High end Indian Bed, Bedroom pillows. Luxury Mattress Bangalore enjoys the top Brought in & Good quality Worldwide Bed.

    Luxury Mattress Bangalore

  • Web design Bangalore could be ensuring that your own buyer dreams as well as dreams regarding the things with the individual technique. Web design Bangalore could be your own squads involving genuinely qualified, experienced as well as experienced website creative designers. Web design Bangalore stores an audio understanding of World Wide Web creating as well as building with the broad range about firms. Web design Bangalore creative designers as well as programmers.

    Web design Bangalore

  • Website design Bangalore we have been positioned in Bangalore at Asia. Website design Bangalore we have been any team associated with hugely aggravated along with ground-breaking fitters as well as other expert. Website design Bangalore can be possessing obtained this trust associated with 2000+ customers by offering these phones carry their particular small business. Website design Bangalore can be brand new top along with generates more substantial conversions.

    Website design Bangalore

  • Website Designing Bangalore is affirmatively updated to the varied improving. Website Designing Bangalore technologies and is always keen of incorporating the aforesaid into the developed client projects in accordance to their requirements. Website Designing Bangalore is these technologies instilled with Web Solution have provided more effective and productive solutions for our clients in recent past.

    Website Designing Bangalore

  • Luxury Mattress Bangalore is knitting with choice outlines on agreeable stretchable white. Luxury Mattress Bangalore is much milder when contrasted with boned spring one. Luxury Mattress Bangalore Consistent outline up-degree in Extravagance Indian Bedding, Pads. Luxury Mattress Bangalore enjoys the Best Foreign made & Great Quality Global Bedding. Extravagance sleeping cushion Bangalore is give Transported in bedding sticking to Worldwide Brand gauges.

    Luxury Mattress Bangalore

  • Buy Online Mattress brings to you one of the biggest collection of mattresses online. Buy Online Mattress that can develop your days and nights with comfort. Buy Online Mattress simply orders your choice of mattress and get it deliver home. Buy Online Mattress there is a wide range of mattresses available with us and you can take your pick with whatever assortment you want.

    Buy Online Mattress

  • I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i….

    Property in BTM layout

  • I want to get across my admiration for your kind-heartedness giving support to those individuals that need help on this particular area. Your special dedication to passing the solution along ended up being quite helpful and has consistently permitted i….

    Property in BTM 2nd stage